TABLE of CONTENTS: Annexes
1. Holistic management in pictures
2. Instructional format of the modules
3. Graphic support material for the modules
6. Suggested implementation scenarios
![]() | The bespectacled crocodileby John HallAn illustrated manual for facilitating Holistic Management in pastoral communities. |
Some rights reserved. You may copy and distribute this manual or parts of it if you (1) credit the original authors, (2) include this notice, including the copyright license information below, and (3) on partial copies, include the following link where people may download the complete manual. English and French versions are available at
http://managingwholes.com/crocodile/
You may create and distribute derivative works, adaptations, and translations under the same conditions. If possible, please make an electronic copy available for public distribution (you can do this through ManagingWholes.com), and send the URL to the author:
If you wish to use this manual for commercial purposes, please contact the author.
Creative Commons license:
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/1.0/
![]()
|
|
ANNEX # 1 |
||||||
|
|
|
|
|||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
|||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
|||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
Module |
Summary of pedagogical objectives (i.e., participants shall be able …) |
Summary of activities |
|
|
Instructional Unit: Outreach (4 modules; duration: 6 to 7 hours)
|
|||
|
1. |
Trust building (2 hrs.) |
· To express oneself freely; to feel at ease and participate |
· Customary greetings, · introductions; · Informal discussion with unserialized posters
|
|
2. |
The whole to be managed (45 min.) |
· To describe the resources and their users, and explain why all the latter must be involved |
· Illustration of the whole to be managed; ·
participants
create a map of their village |
|
3. |
Community organization (2-3 hrs.) |
· To design appropriate forms of community organization |
· Inventory of forms of organization and of roles performed within the community; ·
Analysis of
roles and responsibilities to be assumed |
|
4 |
Conflict prevention (30 min.) |
To develop conflict prevention and resolution strategies |
· Lead-in exercise on exclusion vs. inclusion, to demonstrate the importance of the concept; · Brainstorming sessions on potential conflicts; · Use of story with a gap to help in delineating a prevention strategy.
|
Instructional Unit: Holistic goal (3 modules; duration: 3 hours)
|
|||
|
5 |
Quality of life (1 hr.) |
· To make a distinction between quality of life and the means of achieving it; · To explain the various ways of attaining the same goal
|
· Demonstration: the 3 stones of the hearth as a symbol of the 3 components of the goal ·
Participants
express the village’s “hopes and dreams” by using the unserialized posters
(holistic goal) |
|
6 |
Production (1 hr.) |
· To explain the importance of all production activities taken as a whole; · To explain how new activities envisioned can enable people to achieve a certain quality of life.
|
· Brainstorming session (with unserialized posters) on production activities compatible with the quality of life expressed by the community; |
|
7 |
Landscape (1 hr.) |
· To explain how it is possible to restore the environment; · To describe the future landscape |
· Introduction, using an open-ended story, to the idea that the environment can be improved; · Brainstorming session (with unserialized posters) on the future landscape envisaged by the community
|
|
Instructional Unit: Ecosystem’s building blocks (4 modules; duration: 3 to 4 hours)
|
|||
|
8 |
Water cycle (1 hr.) |
· To explain the water cycle; · To explain the relationship between “effective” water, soil caping, and percolation |
· Demonstration: the four pillars of a house as an introduction to this unit; · Participants create a concrete representation of the water cycle using the unserialized posters; ·
Demonstration
of compacted vs. loosened soils |
|
9 |
Nutrient cycle (1 hr.) |
· To explain the nutrient cycle · To explain the relationship between soil fertility and the nutrient cycle; |
· Participants establish a concrete representation of the nutrient cycle using the unserialized posters;
|
|
10 |
Energy flow (30 min.) |
· To explain the role of soil, water and sun in forage production |
· Participants establish a concrete representation of energy flow using the unserialized posters;
|
|
11 |
Succession (1 hr.) |
· To explain the relationship between succession and biodiversity · To explain the relationship between biodiversity and stability; |
· Exercise to establish a ladder of succession using unserialized posters; · Brainstorming session on vanished plant and animal species; ·
Discussion
of relationship between succession, biodiversity and stability; |
|
Instructional Unit: Tools (5 modules; duration: 4 to 5 hours)
|
|||
|
12 |
Animal impact (45 min.) |
· To explain the potencially positive impact of livestock on soil crust and vegetation ·
To explain
how animal impact is a tool that can be chosen like any other
|
· Introduction to the concept of animal impact by means of a series of images (e.g., stampeding herd); · Discussion of the relationship between animal impact and building blocks of the ecosystem |
|
13 |
Grazing and rest (1 hr.) |
·
To explain
the positive impact of rational grazing upon vegetation |
·
Analysis of
3 series of images: differences between overgrazing, rational grazing and
prolonged rest. |
|
14 |
Time (1 hr.) |
· To explain the effect of controlling time on pasture regeneration; · To explain the consequences of a failure to control time |
· (Introduction of the instructional unit (daba, scythe, axe, etc.) · Story/anecdote to introduce the concept of time; · Analysis of 2 series of images to point up notions of resting time and the dangers of continuous grazing; · Concluding role-play.
|
|
15 |
Fire (1 hr.) |
· To explain the positive or negative impact of fire, depending on the circumstances; ·
To explain
how fire is a tool that can be chosen like any other |
· To be established at a later date; |
|
16 |
Technologies (1 hr.) |
· To explain the difference between technologies and other tools discussed in this unit |
· Brainstorming session on the best-known technologies; ·
Exercise
comparing technologies with other tools |
|
Instructional Unit: Testing guidelines (7 modules; 5 hours)
|
|||
|
17 |
Weak link (1 hr.) |
· To explain that the ecosystem functions like a chain with interconnected links; ·
Identification
and strengthening of the weakest link. |
· Introduction to the unit through presentation of the “filter” · Explanation of the game · “Weak Link” game · Utilization of results |
|
18
|
Cause and effect (30 min.) |
· To distinguish the cause from its effects.
|
·
Card game:
participants must distinguish for a given issue, its cause from its effect |
|
19 |
Ecosystem as a whole (30 min.) |
· To explain the possible impact of decisions upon the ecosystem, and why it must be taken into consideration |
·
Game about
impact on the ecosystem: the “candidate tools” must go before a “jury” made
up of building blocks of the ecosystem before they can be accepted. |
|
20 |
Additional resources (30 min.) |
· To explain the idea of additional resources; · To identify the optimal allocation in view of a given objective; |
·
Investment
game: players can “invest” (with play money) in the tool they think will have
the maximum yield in view of the goal being pursued. |
|
21 |
External dependence (45 min.) |
· To evaluate their own capacity to ensure the sustainability of investments
|
· Game: brainstorming session and comparison of resources needed for two different technologies
|
|
22 |
Society and culture (45 min.) |
·
To evaluate
the acceptability of a given action for the various human groups both within
and outside of the community |
· Role-playing in which participants identify and discuss the importance of the test |
|
23 |
Synthesis of tests (1 hr.) |
· To explain why tools must be tested; ·
To use the
battery of 6 tests; |
· Participants review in turn several tools using the pocket chart; |
|
Instructional Unit: Management principles (5 modules; 4 to 5 hours)
|
|||
|
24 |
Plants to be promoted (1 hr.) |
· To choose forrage plants the development of which would improve the quality of grazing lands
|
· Introduction to the instructional unit: the bricks used to build the wall; · Brainstorming session on potential plants, followed by a brainstorming session on selection criteria · Choice of plants to be promoted, using a pocket chart |
|
25 |
mRT: minimum resting time (1 hr.) |
· To determine the mRT (in rainy and dry seasons) of plants that herders want to rehabilitate |
· Series of images to outline the mRT concept; ·
Discussion
and determination by the group of mRTs of plants to be promoted |
|
26 |
MGT: maximum grazing time (45 min.) |
· To determine the MGT (in rainy and dry seasons) of plants that the population wants to rehabilitate |
· Series of images to outline the MGT concept; ·
Discussion
and determination by the group of MGTs for plants to be promoted |
|
27 |
Overgrazing (1 hr.) |
·
To explain
the relationship between adherence to the mRTs and MGTs of plants to be
rehabilitated and the process of overgrazing |
· Game using candy to introduce the concept of selection; · Open-ended story (illustrated) and discussion to develop the concept of overgrazing |
|
28 |
mRT, MGT and division into paddocks (1 hr.) |
· To determine the number of paddocks needed in order to adhere to the mRTs and MGTs of species to be promoted |
· Interactive presentation of the idea of dividing grazing land into paddocks; ·
2 practical
exercises: one concrete example and one based on species to be promoted |
Instructional Unit: Planing of grazing (4 modules; 4 to 5 hours)
|
|||
|
29 |
Range-land mapping (90 min.) |
· To divide the grazing area into paddocks, indicate the boundaries of these paddocks, and identify them by assigning names to them. |
· Presentation of the instructional unit: hand, ballpoint pen and notebook · Production of the map 1) in the dirt and 2) on paper; · Discussion of markers, division of site into paddocks and naming of paddocks ·
Walk-through
of paddocks, followed by a discussion of how to go about creating them. |
|
30 |
Relative value of paddocks (1 hr.) |
· To gauge the relative value of each paddock and program livestock movements |
|